Global Health Initiative Boosts Cross-Cultural Education

Month-long KPSOM clinical rotation to Kenya centers on multi-disciplinary rounding, new partnerships, and cultural humility

November 27, 2023

KPSOM students gather outside of Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital during the AMPATH exchange program in Eldoret, Kenya.

KPSOM students gather outside of Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital during the AMPATH exchange program in Eldoret, Kenya.

“I highly recommend it! It was an incredible experience and easily ranks as my favorite rotation in medical school."

 - Emilia Zevallos-Roberts on her visit to Eldoret, Kenya as part of the AMPATH Consortium

Kaiser Permanente Bernard J. Tyson (KPSOM) students Isabelle “Izzie” Franklin, Ellie Fratt, Benjamin Metrikin, and Emilia Zevallos-Roberts were part of a consortium of students from varied North American and European universities to take part in the Academic Model Providing Access to Healthcare’s (AMPATH) unique medical trainee exchange program in Eldoret, Kenya in August 2023. Through a partnership between AMPATH, Moi University, and Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital (MTRH), these KPSOM students were integrated into an internal medicine-focused rounding team in four-week inpatient rotations along with a Kenyan multidisciplinary team of faculty called consultants; Kenyan registrars, who are the equivalent of US residents; fourth- and sixth-year Kenyan medical students who follow the British medical education system; a clinical officer, which is similar to a US nurse practitioner; and, at times, nurses and pharmacists.

(Left) KPSOM student Isabelle Franklin poses with Kenyan colleagues from her Internal Medicine rounding team.  (Right) Dean Mark Schuster poses with KPSOM students Ellie Frat and Benjamin Metrikin, and Dr. Jeff Brettler, outside of IU House.

(Left) KPSOM student Isabelle Franklin poses with Kenyan colleagues from her Internal Medicine rounding team. 

(Right) Dean Mark Schuster poses with KPSOM students Ellie Frat and Benjamin Metrikin, and Dr. Jeff Brettler, outside of IU House.

Cross-Cultural Exchange

The KPSOM quartet was led by Jeff Brettler, MD, KPSOM Director of Global Health and Assistant Professor of Health Systems Science, who stated the goal of the program is to deepen students’ proficiency in history and physical exam skills, expose students to a different healthcare delivery system they can compare and contrast with US healthcare systems, encourage the development of communication skills, including effective cross-cultural communication, and incorporate cultural humility as an ongoing theme throughout the month-long program.

Dr. Brettler said the students successfully accomplished these objectives while serving as “amazing ambassadors” who “represented the school extremely well” during its first formal experience with the AMPATH consortium. The students’ experience in Eldoret was quite different from what they would experience clinically, culturally, and structurally in the US, including the use of the Kiswahili language and even how health information is obtained. In addition to their time rounding in hospitals and learning in local clinics, KPSOM students were able to bond with their colleagues and Moi medical students whom they invited to IU House—the Eldoret compound where the KPSOM group resided—for lunches and dinners. Some members of the integrated teams also watched soccer matches together and learned more about each other and pressing social issues during weekly fireside chats. 

While Dr. Brettler and the students acknowledged the impossibility of learning everything about different cultures, they shared that having cultural humility, or an interest in understanding and appreciating the culture of others, was key in this experience in addition to having flexibility, leaning on and learning from their Kenyan team members, and being a careful observer of cultural norms.

When the KPSOM students were not rounding with their teams, the group was able to coordinate a weekend day trip that included a hike with Dr. Brettler, and students had enough downtime to bond with one another, peers, and even work on residency applications. Fratt said the group really loved being in the lush city of Eldoret and enjoyed spending time at IU House. The group even ventured to Eldoret’s picturesque Torok Falls the week before their cultural exchange began and Fratt described the city as “a fun, beautiful place to be.”

Considering that KPSOM students and global health initiative staff had discussions stateside about cultural humility, Zevallos-Roberts said these discussions also carried over to the AMPATH group. “I think the most important thing is knowing the power and privilege that your status comes with and being very careful about wielding that power.”

 “The cultural practices are different, so [our students] really … have to learn everything through all of those different aspects,” Dr. Brettler added. “The biggest learnings [were] around approach to clinical diagnosis and management when you don't have all of the resources that you have in a high-resource setting like the United States, so there is increased emphasis on history and physical exam. There is [an] increased emphasis on creating a differential diagnosis based upon much more limited information than you would in a setting like the United States, so it really expands [the students’] thought process[es] and their actual way of approaching clinical problems.”

Partnership and Bidirectional Exchanges

The Global Health Office’s mission philosophy is a tripartite approach that includes the training of clinicians, clinical care collaboration, and research. KPSOM and AMPATH aim to ensure those components are bidirectional with benefit to both participating parties, which is why KPSOM plans to bring its students to Kenya annually and is committed to hosting and facilitating the training of Kenyan medical students on KPSOM’s campus in the very near future; this is a goal the global health initiative team is actively working toward.

As students took part in their rotations, Dr. Brettler was involved in many other aspects of the Eldoret cultural exchange. For instance, he met with AMPATH faculty and staff to develop relationships to begin clinical work in population health around hypertension and chronic disease management, an area of personal interest. This area of focus is particularly key due to the country’s under-resourced nature and lack of significant health infrastructure outside of its emphasis on HIV and AIDS. Dr. Brettler and KPSOM students also spent time in the HIV clinic where there is a need to integrate chronic disease into HIV care, a project Dr. Brettler is looking forward to tackling. The aim of these efforts was to better understand workflows, the clinic’s electronic system, what kind of data was collected, and how the teams could work collaboratively.

(left) KPSOM students gather outside of IU House along with Internal Medicine team lead Lu’aie Kailani. (right) Dean Mark Schuster visits the Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital Comprehensive Care Clinic along with Evelyn Too, supervisor of the AMPATH Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital HIV clinic, and Dr. Jeff Brettler.

(left) KPSOM students gather outside of IU House along with Internal Medicine team lead Lu’aie Kailani.

(right) Dean Mark Schuster visits the Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital Comprehensive Care Clinic along with Evelyn Too, supervisor of the AMPATH Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital HIV clinic, and Dr. Jeff Brettler.

The cultural exchange was also marked by a visit from Mark Schuster, MD, PhD, KPSOM Founding Dean and CEO, who ventured to Eldoret during the second week of the students’ rotations. Dr. Brettler helped coordinate the itinerary for Dean Schuster’s visit, which included various tours of the hospital and meetings with counterparts at Moi University School of Medicine. As he accompanied Dean Schuster during his four-day visit, Dr. Brettler was able to share more details on AMPATH and the deep, long-standing partnership between the consortium’s North American and European universities, Moi University, and Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital (MTRH).

“I think he was impressed with the depth and the history of that partnership and a lot of the outcomes that have resulted as a consequence of that wonderful … very bidirectional relationship,” said Dr. Brettler. “He's a pediatrician, so we made sure that he had the opportunity to see all the pediatric-related areas … and he was able to participate on rounds and see what the students’ day-to-day actually looked like. I think that was a great opportunity for him to see both the nuts and bolts of the student experience as well as obtain a better understanding of how the consortium is constructed and what this global health rotation is really about.”

Clinical Care Collaboration

In addition to Dean Schuster’s visit, Mudit Mathur, MD, MBA, FAAP, FCCM, CPPS, KPSOM Associate Professor of Clinical Science, also joined the KPSOM group in Eldoret. Dr. Mathur, a San Bernardino County-based pediatric intensivist, has a wealth of experience in pediatric critical care training and education. He is a certified instructor of Pediatric Fundamentals, a class that focuses on critical care support, which he has taught all over the world. Dr. Mathur has also helped open up pediatric intensive care units in different parts of the world.

This experience is highly relevant to MTRH because, in spite of the hospital having a large referral area for approximately 25 million Kenyans (and some Ugandans) and serving as the only public pediatric hospital in Western Kenya, MTRH does not have pediatric critical care capacity, said Dr. Brettler. Therefore, if no bed is available in the adult intensive care unit (ICU) when children are sick at MTRH, they, unfortunately, have very poor outcomes because of the inability to escalate care.

To address this challenge, Dr. Mathur took part in clinical care collaboration with colleagues from Moi University and Indiana University, as well as a couple of pediatric intensivists, to affect pediatric critical care capacity. While in Eldoret, he spent extensive time rounding with varied members of the MTRH team—including nurses, pediatricians, and adult ICU physicians—who all staffed the adult ICU. In addition, Dr. Mather gave a number of lectures on pediatric critical care issues and began assessing what materials and equipment would be needed to improve pediatric critical care onsite. For instance, Dr. Mather evaluated a storage and overflow area that will ultimately be transformed into a pediatric ICU, and he assessed a SIM lab that will later be used for training and a pediatric emergency room—both spaces have significant equipment needs.

Clinician Training

Dr. Mathur and colleagues are also planning to offer a Pediatric Fundamental Critical Care Support (PFCCS) course in the near future, which would enable a variety of MTRH staff to increase their pediatric critical care skills and awareness in a train-the-trainer course model that could be offered several times in succession. This standard would allow Kenyan faculty to become trained, and then subsequently train and certify other members of the MTRH, which would greatly expand the catchment area in a new clinical collaborative partnership between Moi, KPSOM, and Indiana University.

KPSOM students join Dr. Jeff Brettler and a guide (at center) for a hike at Torok Falls during a day trip leading up to the AMPATH exchange program in Eldoret, Kenya.

KPSOM students join Dr. Jeff Brettler and a guide (at center) for a hike at Torok Falls during a day trip leading up to the AMPATH exchange program in Eldoret, Kenya.

Challenges: Late-Stage Illnesses and a Health Insurance Dearth

As with any new venture, there oftentimes are unavoidable challenges that are part and parcel to the process. Fratt explained feeling a bit emotionally unprepared for the levels of suffering she encountered with patients who often had late-stage presentations of diseases. Patient illnesses ranged from very late-stage cancers, HIV and AIDS-related complications, extrapulmonary tuberculosis, malaria, neglected tropical diseases, and other illnesses that occur more commonly in lower-resource settings. Similarly, several students explained having to adjust to a resource-constrained setting. Because many Kenyan patients often have to pay for tests and labs such as imaging studies, biopsies, etc. ordered by medical staff, students were forced to cautiously evaluate next steps because typical solutions were not always affordable based on the patient’s health coverage.

“There is another very significant layer of complexity to [students’] evaluation and management [of] patients - understanding from a value proposition how much these tests cost, and [determining] if they are really needed both for the diagnosis and the management of the patients,” said Dr. Brettler. “So, there's a whole different set of learnings and thought processes around management in a lower-resource setting than they're used to.”

There is a large effort aimed at covering the Kenyan population with a National Hospital Insurance Fund  (the equivalent of national health insurance), which covers catastrophic care of hospitalizations and some limited outpatient and preventive care. This option, however, is not completely comprehensive. Universal health coverage rates are as high as 30 or 40 percent within the AMPATH catchment area, but only about half that rate in the rest of the country, explained Dr. Brettler. The vast majority of patients do not have health insurance and are unable to go to clinics or health centers for routine problems and patients are presenting only when they are in absolutely dire need, therefore learning to diagnose and manage late-stage presentations of diseases is key.

A Focus on Equity

With this in mind, Dr. Brettler says he would love to see all KPSOM students pursue a career in which equity is the central mission and motivation of their daily profession, which completely aligns with the mission and values of the school. 

“Studies show that students and residents who participate in global health experiences are more likely to go into primary care fields,” said Dr. Brettler. “And more importantly, are more likely to go into under-resourced communities for their career. And I think the importance of that really can't be understated overstated. Many global health experts are considering renaming global health to global health equity, so this really is about equity.”

He added, “I think this experience absolutely cements the importance of that. And just anecdotally and personally, I know that anyone who participates in a global health experience ends up having a more expansive view of the communities that they really should be involved with [and gain] a better appreciation for cultural humility and the truly devastating equities issues that we see both in our local communities and in our global communities. And regardless of where students end up practicing, I think this kind of experience just goes a long way in really reinforcing our mission and values.”